Senate committee advances NASA and FCC nominees with no Democrats in the room
Full credit
File:NASA Science Calendar 2021.pdf / NASA This image was created with Adobe InDesign . / https://eospso.nasa.gov/https%3A/eospso.gsfc.nasa.gov/publications/2021-nasa-science-calendar ( direct link ) / Wikimedia Commons / Public Domain / https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:NASA_Science_Calendar_2021.pdfSource pageThe Senate Commerce Committee has reported out nominations for two NASA posts and one FCC commissioner seat, although no Democrats attended the session. SpacePolicyOnline reports that the votes went ahead despite a committee rule that normally requires a minority-party senator to be present for official action.
Who was nominated and how the votes went
President Trump put forward Joshua Shoemaker for NASA's Chief Financial Officer role and Robert Steinau for the post of Inspector General. He also named Danielle Thumann Severs to an FCC commissioner seat. The committee had heard all three nominations at a hearing on November 10, held together with a nominee for the Department of Transportation.
All 15 Republican members were present, and each nomination passed 15-0. Chairman Ted Cruz announced that the nominations and several bills were "ordered reported", the committee's term for sending them onward.
Dispute over the quorum
Committee rules require a quorum for official actions, and that has traditionally meant at least one senator from the minority party must take part. Democrats asked Cruz to postpone the vote on Thumann Severs, but Republicans went ahead, and Cruz and others criticised the Democrats for staying away.
Ranking Member Maria Cantwell, who is expected to chair the committee again in January when Democrats take control, said in a statement that her party objects to nominees being rushed through in a lame-duck session. She also said that Anna Gomez, the lone Democrat on the FCC, should be renominated.
Why the FCC seat is contested
Democrats oppose Thumann Severs chiefly because her nomination is not paired with a Democratic nominee, a practice the Senate has long followed. The Shoemaker and Steinau nominations were not controversial.
Thumann Severs is currently Senior Counsel to FCC Chairman Brendan Carr. The commission presently has two Republicans, Carr and Olivia Trusty, who was confirmed last year without a Democratic counterpart. Three members are needed for the FCC to conduct Commission business. Gomez's term expired in June, but she may keep serving in a holdover capacity under the Communications Act, which allows her to remain through the end of 2027.
Concerns about the FCC's independence
The FCC created its own Space Bureau in 2023 as satellite operations boomed with the advent of megaconstellations, and it assigns the radio frequencies satellite operators need to talk to their spacecraft while setting rules on orbital debris. Since its creation in 1934 the agency has been independent and not subject to White House direction, yet on June 29, 2026 the Supreme Court ruled in Trump v. Slaughter. Democrats fear that once a third Republican joins the panel, Trump will fire Gomez.
Open questions
- Will the full Senate confirm Thumann Severs without a paired Democratic nominee?
- Will Gomez be renominated, or removed once a third Republican joins the FCC?