AI may not work like the human brain after all, scientists discover
What happened
Researchers found that even AI models that closely predict brain activity may rely on internal processes the brain doesn't use, raising important questions about their reliability in neuroscience research. "Until now, scientists mostly tested this in one direction. They asked whether AI models can predict brain activity."
A New Test Reveals a Hidden Problem With Brain-Like AI The York University team decided to approach this question from the opposite direction.
A new study from York University has uncovered a surprising weakness in AI models that are widely used to understand how the brain processes visual information. For years, researchers have relied on artificial neural networks (ANNs), computer systems designed to perform tasks such as recognizing objects in images, to investigate how vision works.
Over the past decade, these models have become some of the leading tools for explaining the brain's visual system. Their ability to reproduce patterns of brain activity has made them especially valuable in neuroscience.
Rather than simply measuring how well AI could predict the activity of brain cells, they investigated whether recorded brain activity could also predict what was happening inside the AI models. If these systems truly operate like the brain, the researchers reasoned, the relationship should work in both directions.
To investigate, they developed a method called reverse predictivity testing, which allowed them to evaluate similarities that conventional tests could overlook. The research team, which included York Postdoctoral Fellow Sabine Muzellec, a trainee with the university's Connected Minds program, examined responses to a wide variety of visual images.