Anthropic researcher claims Claude helped prove Riemann hypothesis
An Anthropic mathematician says he used Claude to solve the Riemann hypothesis, one of mathematics' most difficult open problems. Levent Alpöge presented the proposed proof on Friday, November 20, but independent mathematicians have yet to examine it.
What Alpöge has published
Alpöge has published a four-page explanation of his reasoning alongside an extensive set of Lean verification files, which allow the logic to be tested with software. He made the announcement on his personal website, and Anthropic has not issued an official statement on the claim.
According to Alpöge, his work goes further than the original problem and establishes the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis (GRH). He also believes the method could readily extend to the Extended Riemann Hypothesis.
Why the problem carries such weight
Bernhard Riemann proposed the hypothesis in 1859 and gave the problem its name. It holds that prime numbers are not random but follow a determined pattern. The Clay Mathematics Institute states that the hypothesis asserts all interesting solutions of ζ(s) = 0 lie on a certain vertical straight line, and that this has been checked for the first 10,000,000,000,000 solutions. A proof covering every interesting solution would clarify many mysteries about the distribution of primes.
Scientific American calls the problem the North Star of number theory and the most famous open problem in mathematics. Until recently it was regarded as so insurmountable that experts did not seriously try to work on it.
What remains unconfirmed
The claim currently rests on Alpöge's own announcement. Independent mathematicians must still examine the proof before anyone can declare the problem solved, and confirming whether Claude has actually contributed will take some time. The timing also draws attention, since the announcement came in the same week Anthropic was floated on the Nasdaq in its initial public offering.
The case recalls an earlier episode in which OpenAI was reported to have helped produce a breakthrough on the Navier-Stokes problem, a finding overshadowed by a plagiarism controversy. Alpöge has also said he finds the outcome saddening.
Open questions
- Will independent mathematicians confirm that the proof is correct?
- Will the claim about the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis hold up under scrutiny?