WORLDTECH NEWS Global technology intelligence.Contact
Technology SINGLE SOURCE

UK can’t keep its Apple encryption order secret, tribunal rules

Modern workstation setup showcasing laptop, smartphone, and financial data for business use.
Illustrative photo.Photo by Leeloo The First on PexelsApple logo shown for identification only; no affiliation with or endorsement of WORLDTECH is implied.

What happened

Privacy UK can’t keep its Apple encryption (scrambling data so only the holder of the key can read it) order secret, tribunal rules Judges found that officials had briefed newspapers about the order while the Home Office refused to confirm it. Until now the Home Office had refused to confirm or deny it had served one on Apple. Apple is a software and consumer electronics company based in Cupertino.

The Times and the Financial Times had reported that government sources confirmed the order. The tribunal found that those briefings took place, and that ministers, senior officials or special advisers authorised them.

The UK government can no longer keep its Apple encryption order secret, a tribunal has ruled. The Home Office had argued that confirming the order would damage national security.

The Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected that claim in a judgment on Thursday. The order is a technical capability notice under the Investigatory Powers Act 2016.

Much of Apple’s challenge can now be heard in public next year. Such notices can require companies to change how their services work so the authorities can get access to data.

“Anyone with even a passing interest in this topic already knows that the respondent has served a technical capability notice on Apple,” the three judges wrote. Briefings the judges said were authorised The judges said the government had not kept to its own secrecy policy.

Key facts

  • Privacy UK can’t keep its Apple encryption order secret, tribunal rules Judges — found: that officials had briefed newspapers about the order while the Home Office refused to confirm it
  • The tribunal — found: that those briefings took place, and that ministers, senior officials or special advisers authorised them

Sources & evidence